The 5 Best Quarterbacks in Football History

Football fans can argue for hours over who’s the best quarterback of all time, but only a limited pool of contenders really deserves the title. Talent, championships, records, leadership—it all comes into play. While we can’t settle every debate, here’s our list of five of the best quarterbacks in football history.

1. Tom Brady

Love him or hate him, you can’t deny Tom Brady’s dominance. With seven Super Bowl wins and five Super Bowl MVP awards, Brady shattered records during his two decades in the NFL. From his laser-sharp passing to his unshakable composure under pressure, his consistency makes him a nightmare for defenders and a legend for the New England Patriots (and later the Tampa Bay Buccaneers).

2. Joe Montana

Nicknamed Joe Cool for his calm demeanor in high-stakes games, Joe Montana led the San Francisco 49ers to four Super Bowl victories. Known for his precision and ability to deliver clutch throws under pressure, Montana epitomized the art of quarterbacking. His iconic connection with Jerry Rice earned him multiple MVPs and a permanent spot in NFL history as one of the greatest leaders and playmakers. His legacy is part of what makes Joe Montana cards so valuable for sports card collectors everywhere!

3. Peyton Manning

Peyton Manning’s football career was a masterclass in intelligence, preparation, and execution. Known as The Sheriff, Manning ran offenses like an orchestra conductor, memorizing every defensive scheme possible. With two Super Bowl wins and five NFL MVP awards, his meticulous game management and cannon arm set him apart. He turned the Indianapolis Colts into perennial contenders and left a trail of broken records in his wake.

4. Johnny Unitas

Before Montana and Brady, there was Johnny Unitas. Known for his gritty toughness and pinpoint accuracy, Unitas helped make the modern quarterback position what it is today. Leading the Baltimore Colts to three championships, he set an NFL record for throwing a touchdown pass in 47 consecutive games. Beyond the numbers, Unitas’s impact on the game endures as foundational to the sport we know today.

5. Patrick Mahomes

He’s still writing his story, but Patrick Mahomes’s meteoric rise with the Kansas City Chiefs has already cemented his spot in football lore. With absurd arm strength, jaw-dropping improvisation, and incredible field vision, Mahomes has redefined what’s possible at the position. Just eight years into his NFL career, he’s already earned two league MVPs, two Super Bowl victories, and countless highlight reels.

Do you agree with this list of the five best quarterbacks in football history? Let us know your thoughts and who you would add to the mix!